Sunday, August 13, 2006

The Pall at Mall

[This story was published by Deccan Herald on 31/Dec/2006. The link is here (or):]

I looked at my watch again. She had said 9.45. She was late. I looked around me. The mall wore a strange forlorn look. A cleaning woman mopped the floor. Her mouth drooped and her eyes stared at the floor as her hands moved pushing the mop this way and that.

What did she think of all that she saw here? I wondered. The abundance. The greed. Hungry mouths. Grasping hands… I shuddered. Malls frightened me.

"Are you out of your mind?" I had said when she suggested we meet at Garuda Mall.

"At that hour, you don't have to worry about the crowds," she had said with a laugh. "Think of it as a social experiment. A mall at an unmall-like hour. What happens there? Bring your notebook. You can make notes…"

I had smiled into the phone. Divya could be funny, and persuasive. Garuda mall was too much in the heart of the city and I had wanted to avoid driving in the Friday night traffic. So I had proposed a newer mall that had come up at the outskirts, still incomplete, but occupied enough with shops to loiter around; or help conduct ‘social experiments’ that Divya had suggested. She had agreed.

Here I was, waiting for Divya to turn up, biting into one of the small chocolate bars I had bought to satiate hunger and boredom – I had bought a couple for Divya as she loved those; As I was killing time going up and down the floors, shopping at windows that were downing their shutters, avoiding weird look from the shop keepers, I noticed something beyond the cleaning women. In one of the dimly lighted corners that had an offset into the toilet areas that was still incomplete.

There was this girl, about 10, wearing clothes that was neat, but clearly old and frayed at the corners. She was feeding the boy of, perhaps just over 2 years old. The way she ran up to the cleaning women, talked to her, it was obvious that the woman was her mother; with the mother busy, the girl had taken up the role of mothering her brother. Alongside the construction materials, there were a stack of papers, from which she picked one to clean-up her brother after the feed.

I settled down at the one of the ornate benches, and watched. As the women came closer to the seating area to clean-up, I lifted my legs up to help her swab the floor; she looked up to me in thanks and I smiled at her. She returned the smile reluctantly; her son came running up to her playing catch and run with her sister; the woman with a resigned admiration, like any other mother, let the kid climb over her and push her. I took one chocolate bar that I had and held it out for the kid – the kid looked to his mother for approval and tentatively took it – and then ran with unadulterated joy, screaming out his sister’s name.

I started making small talk with the cleaning women. In any case I was killing time, waiting for Divya to show up. In a few minutes, I heard the oft-said story about a poor woman in India – Santhamma’s husband was a drunkard and had left her only to return to beat her up for money. She takes care of her children; her daughter goes to school sporadically; but of late with her brother in the family the living was taking its toll. The daughter had started doing odd jobs and graduating to regular jobs. Santhamma was repentant that her daughter could not go to school, but she had no way out. Her daughter earned some money that helped feed the family and very basic needs and help retain their dignity; there was no help from any other quarters.

Santhamma moved on and yet no sign of Divya; I sighed and called her on the mobile and it was not reachable. “Damn Networks”, I muttered. I looked at my watch, it was 10.45 and the mall-security in his beat gave me the strange looks; there were just couple of shops still open.

I saw the girl do a ruck-sack kind of carrier around her back and she lifted it to her back along with her brother. She gave the sheaf of paper to her brother who playfully handed one to her, as she walked to every shop and slipped one under the door. It looked like some ‘notice’. I saw Divya walking in with a smile. I waved to her and motioned her to wait a while; as the girl moved closer to the shop behind me, curious, I reached out for the notice and took one to read it.

As I read it, I was stuck the incongruity of it; I could feel my anger rising – I was getting incensed. Then the futility hit me; and I laughed out loud, at the irony of it all. The girl, puzzled, went about her work that would help put food on the floor for the family.

Divya took the notice from my hand and read it aloud,

“Whomsoever it blah, blah… … Government of India blah, blah, …, ban any children under the age of 14 employed blah. You hereby have time till 30th of September 2006 to comply with this order… blah”.

I walked up to the girl, gave her the remaining chocolate bar. Her eyes lit up. I quickly averted her eyes, took Divya’s hand and walked out of the mall. I’ve had my social experiment for the day, perhaps for a long time to come. As a 52 year old mother, holding my daughters hand, I had trouble deciding if the Government decision was right or wrong for someone else’s daughter.


Author’s Note: I wrote this story for The starting lines of the story were already published as a part of “kathe Korner”; that story needs to complete those lines. Those lines are the ones in italics.
The winning Story is at:


ramesh said...

wondering what the girl would have done if she was literate and could read the notice?? probably she would have still carried on what she did...

Edwin said...

The story reads well - es

brij said...

when you have so much talent, it also becomes a responsibility to ensure that it is wisely put to use. wishing you - nothing but the best!

The Soliloquist said...

great theme, good plot... and lovely end... but the flow could ve been a little crsiper...found the word "tentative" and "looked up in thanks" being used repetitively....but on the whole, very very original.... had all the elements of a good short story..

EnGeetham aka "My Song!" said...

4Ramesh: Perhaps, yes. This is where, I really cannot separate "right" from the "good", when they are at odds. She should have an education is something required. But its also required that the family can live, with their dignity intact.

4Edwin: Thanks.

4Brij: Thanks, but "you mock me" (say it like John Malkovich). But modesty is not my virtue, so I accept it gracefully ! :)

4Sol: Thanks for the critique/comment. With Nandri's (since I should not repeat words :) to, i went ahead and changed those. Do come back & with your comments on other stuff onboard. I want to further my illusions of being a writer ! :)

Dinaker said...

This truly is reality :) the way it's put across brings the events in front of one's eyes. Bringing in a law isn't a solution, but do we have a way out ? we are far far away from it ....

Anonymous said...

Nice stuff, but somewhat heavy on the message bit. You could be more subtle. That paper thing was really unnecessary. The setting is adequate to carry the narrative and conclusion.

Kali's Angel

EnGeetham aka "My Song!" said...

4D'kar: True, true

4KA: Thanks for the input; coming from a pro, I'll take it.

Anonymous said...

Your twist at the end - was good!

Rather a peculiar 52 year old mother, preferring outskirts at unearthly
hours, eating chocolates and muttering : "Damn Networks". => More like a
fond father with lot of love for kids!
- sg

mg said...

Though the twist was good, it kind of supressed the heavy social message.

varun said...

may sound silly. but somewhere i got a feeling that its a plot worked backwards.... maybe its the inherent desire to keep the ending perfect..

will take nothing away from the plot though. this comment is to all the perfect endings in future..
- cheers

EnGeetham aka "My Song!" said...

4SG: Actually, I started it as a "dad"; as i was writing it in, i changed it to mother.

4MyBetHalf: So, no to twists, yes to Karuthu ? (i'm getting it, slowly :)

4VV: Pefect Endings ? Where are they, in real life ? :) Anyways, keep coming back.

Anonymous said...

Good "karuthu". the twist was a real twist..but I am glad it was not strong enough to make me move away from the karuthu..BTW I am all for the "mother".. why should a 52 yr old mother not eat chocolate or swear? Glad you are not a MCP

EnGeetham aka "My Song!" said...

4accs: Thanks. Not sure about a whether 52yr old mother would, but I think 46yr old mother does ! :)

rahul said...

Incisive! Yet my opinion stays with banning child labor ... does a greater good!

EnGeetham aka "My Song!" said...

4Rahul: Thanks for stopping by. I'm not so sure sometimes, given that we dont have a systemic alternative... Unless that change is brought in, the law to me is not sustainable.

SS said...

Good story. I especially liked the twist and the buildup to the climax.

DS said...

Good one.

SR said...

A nice story - somehow I would have thought the writer was a woman, if I
hadn't known otherwise